5 Best Compost Choices for Your Garden (2024 Guide)

best compost for garden man with compost

If you’re looking for a way to make your plants thrive in your garden, look no further than compost. Compost is the best way to enrich your soil and make it last longer, while helping your plants to thrive.

Most gardeners find that when they use compost in their garden, their crop yield increases immensely.

If you don’t have time, or space for your own compost pile, the next best thing is to buy compost that is already made and bagged. There are several different options when it comes to compost you can buy, and your gardening needs will determine which one suits you best.

With so many different compost products on the market, how do you know what’s the best compost for your garden? This guide will help you find the best compost to fit your needs AND will look at how to use it properly.

1 | Worm Castings Organic Fertilizer, Wiggle Worm Soil Builder

The Worm Castings Organic Fertilizer is a great option for any gardener looking to increase their productivity. Worm castings are an all-natural, organic fertilizer that can be used on most plants and vegetables. The Worm Castings Organic Fertilizer is made from organically-grown worm castings mixed with soil and other natural ingredients. This product promotes healthy plant growth by balancing the soil’s pH level as well as providing a good amount of nutrients.

It is made up of worm castings (the nutrient-rich waste left behind after worms eat), water, and some minerals. Worm Castings Organic Fertilizer has been shown to promote healthy plant growth and may even make plants more resistant to pests or diseases like powdery mildew or aphids!


Organically grown.

Balances soil pH level.

Makes plants more resistant to pests.


X Pricepoint is usually higher.

2 | Fishnure Organic Humus Compost Fertilizer

Fishnure compost fertilizer contains all-natural ingredients that are safe for people, pets, and the environment. You can use this compost on indoor and outdoor plants. Fishnure’s organic humus compost fertilizer is made from fish manure that has been heat treated into a natural humus through an aerobic fermentation process, without the use of artificial fertilizers or synthetic materials. A one pound bag of Fishnure can cover up to 60 square feet, so you get plenty of coverage for your gardening needs.


Concentrated for maximum coverage.

No fish odor.

Remains in the soil for lasting effects.


X High pricepoint.

3 | Wakefield Compost Hero Biochar Blend

This Wakefield Compost Hero Biochar Blend is a revolutionary compost that will help any gardener increase their crop by 20% or more. Wakefield has developed a specialized blend of compost and biochar to provide the best possible growing conditions for plants. The biochar really makes a difference, as it is a high carbon substance made from organic material. The Wakefield Compost Hero Biochar Blend can be used on indoor or outdoor gardens, container gardens, raised beds, or even in a single pot. Wakefield’s Biochar Blend offers an exclusive combination of soil-building materials, all in one easy-to-use bag!


Puts carbon into the soil.


Feeds soil microbes.


X Comes in a small bag.

4| Blue Ribbon Organic Compost

Blue Ribbon’s compost is made of 100% organic materials and is also certified by the USDA to ensure its safety. This compost is made from brush, cut firewood, garden debris, grass clippings, leaves, sod, vegetable waste, and wood chips. No animal products, including manure, are used in this compost product. The Blue Ribbon compost is odor-free and easy to spread around in the garden. You can add in worm castings, humus, peat moss, or any other soil builder you desire.



Manure-free = odor free

Comes in large quantity


X Small bag.

5 | Michigan Peat 5240 Garden Magic Compost and Manure

Michigan Peat 5240 Garden Magic Compost and Manure is a Michigan peat compost that contains minerals such as iron, potassium, phosphorus and calcium. It is perfect for starting seedlings, or enhancing the growth of mature plants. Michigan peat is naturally rich in organic matter which helps to improve the quality of your soil. Michigan Peat 5240 Compost also contains natural humates which help to make the soil more fertile by improving its ability to retain water. This compost has been tested for weed seeds so you know it’s safe for your garden!


Tested for weed seeds.

Mixes well.

Full of minerals.


X Higher pricepoint.

How to Choose Garden Compost

Gardeners know that compost is a vital part of any successful garden. It helps to fertilize the soil and keep it healthy, which in turn promotes both plant growth and stability.

Compost can be created from many different sources – including leaves, grass clippings, manure, coffee grounds (yes!), orange peels, eggshells…the list goes on.

When you don’t have time to create compost on your own, the next best thing is store-bought compost.

So, how do you know what kind of compost to buy?

Here are some things to take into consideration when you’re deciding which compost you want to buy:

1 | Choose Organic

If you’re looking for a quality compost that will help improve the soil in your garden, look for one that is organic. This means it has been made without any synthetic chemicals or fertilizers.

The problem with synthetic chemicals and fertilizers is that you don’t want to be eating vegetables or fruits that have been grown with them. Health-wise, it’s far better to go the organic route so you aren’t ingesting anything harmful.

It’s also better for the soil to have organic compost. It’s a natural boost, much like boosting your own immune system.

The only downside to organic composts is that they can be harder to find and typically cost more than non-organic options, but they are well worth the cost and hunt to find them.

2 | Worm Castings

If you’re looking for compost that is specifically tailored to meet the needs of your garden, consider buying one that is made from worm castings.

Worm castings are the droppings of earthworms and are packed with nutrients that help plants grow healthy and strong. They also happen to be one of the best types of composts for improving soil structure.

Worm castings make great compost.

3 | Aged Compost

If your main use for the best garden compost is as a soil amendment, then you should look for something that has been aged and contains more organic materials such as leaves or grass clippings. This type of best garden compost will have a higher carbon-to-nitrogen ratio which means that it will break down much slower than other types of best garden composts.

Regardless of which type of compost you choose, make sure to read the label carefully to ensure that it is safe for use in your garden. Some composts contain weed seeds or harmful pathogens that can damage plants.

So, what’s the best garden compost to buy? It really depends on your individual needs and preferences. But, any of the above types are a great choice!

Other Ways to Use Garden Compost

Compost is an important part of any garden. It helps provide nutrients to the soil and keep it healthy, which in turn helps your plants thrive.

But compost also has a lot of other uses.

Here are some other ways you can use compost in your garden:

1 | To increase drainage and aeration: Spread about 3-5 inches on top of the existing dirt before adding new layers or planting anything.

2 | To help kill weeds: Place between rows with seedlings, where weeds are most likely to grow.

3 | As mulch around flowers/vegetables: near sidewalks or roadsides where people will be walking or driving by often (e.g., walkways), as this can prevent people from tracking dirt into your garden.

How to Use Garden Compost

Another thing to keep in mind when buying compost for your garden is that it’s not just about what you put into the soil – but also how you use it.

It can be tempting to pour out one large pile and expect huge results, but this isn’t always the best way to use compost. Instead, spread it over a small area and break up the soil with your hands or a cultivator before adding it. Make sure you use compost that mixes well, so this step is effortless.

Breaking up the soil so the compost mixes in will help ensure that all of those nutrients are fully absorbed by the plants in your garden!

You can also put your compost into a hole that’s been dug before planting. You will still want to mix up the soil and compost a little bit to ensure it is evenly distributed.

And don’t forget…compost is one of several keys to an effective gardening routine. The more you know about what it can do, the better your garden will grow!

How Much Compost Should I Use?

It’s best to add about 10% or 15% (by volume) into the soil and then mix it up really well with the existing dirt.

How Often Should I Add New Compost?

If you’re adding fresh new material, we recommend doing this every 3 months. If you’re adding aged material, we recommend doing this once per year.

Final Thoughts on Finding the Best Garden Compost

Not all compost options are created equally. If you are looking to save time and purchase compost, make sure to do ample research to make sure you are getting what you need for your garden.

If you have additional questions or need help finding the perfect compost, visit your local gardening center to gather more information.

7 Best Pet Safe Weed Killers (2022 Guide)
10 Best Garden Carts (2022 Guide)
14 Best Greenhouse Heaters: 2022 Guide